Auto Expenses aren't guaranteed deductions

Advisor's Edge

2014-03-06


If you use your vehicle to visit clients at their homes or places of business, you’re likely aware that you may be able to get some tax Advisor to Client (Keyword) relief for the expenses associated with operating your vehicle.

But, as a recent case (Showers v The Queen, 2014 TCC 32) demonstrated, your ability to claim motor vehicle expenses is based on whether or not you have kept appropriate receipts and proof of mileage driven.

The taxpayer, Showers, is a cabinet installer and worked for a kitchen company. On his 2008 and 2009 tax returns, he claimed motor vehicle expenses for his pickup truck, amounting to nearly $6,200 and $9,800 respectively, along with GST rebates.

Under the Income Tax Act, if an employee uses his vehicle for work, he can deduct the business portion of the operating expenses from income when he files his tax return. Yet many employees who otherwise might be eligible to claim their motor vehicle expenses choose not to if their employers provide them with per-kilometre reimbursements. As long as this allowance is considered reasonable, it does not have to be included in income and, thus, is tax-free.

For 2014, CRA defines “reasonable” as 54 cents per kilometre for the first 5,000 kilometres and 48 cents thereafter (higher for the territories). For the years in question, 2008 and 2009, the limit was 52 cents for the first 5,000 km, and 46 cents thereafter.

If, however, an employee determines that the allowance her employer pays, although reasonable, doesn’t cover the actual costs of operating the vehicle, the employee can choose to deduct the business portion of her actual operating expenses as long as she includes any allowance received from her employer as income.

Amounts claimed were excessive
The issue that CRA, as well as the Tax Court judge, had with these expenses was that the amounts claimed appeared excessive and lacked “sufficient reliable evidence” to allow CRA and the Court to estimate the proper expenses. While Showers agreed the amounts claimed were excessive, he blamed his tax preparer, adding he’d never actually reviewed his tax returns before signing and submitting them.

He also acknowledged the kilometres driven for employment purposes recorded on Form T777, Statement of Employment Expenses, were inaccurate and the correct number of kilometers was the one reported to his employer for purposes of being reimbursed.

This, in turn, posed an additional problem. Showers’ employer had reimbursed him $0.38 per kilometre, but the taxpayer failed to fully include these reimbursements in his income for the years in question. In 2008, he underreported his reimbursement and, in 2009, he neglected to report any of the amounts he was reimbursed.

Another issue with the taxpayer’s claim was that “most of the items claimed as motor vehicle expenses appear to be unreasonably high.” Yet, despite acknowledging that the amounts claimed were wrong, Showers could produce neither the correct amounts, nor any reasonable estimates. He’d given the receipts to his tax preparer, who was “nowhere to be found.” Showers attempted to argue that he should at least be allowed to claim expenses up to the CRA-approved allowance rates in effect for 2008 and 2009.

But the judge didn’t buy that argument, saying, “The allowance policy does not reflect actual expenses in a particular case and is not meant to. […] These are amounts that the CRA accepts as reasonable allowances that may be paid by employers.” In conclusion, the judge said, given a lack of any receipts, this was “not a case in which the Court should bend over backwards to help a taxpayer who is not able to prove his case.”

The judge disallowed all vehicle expenses claimed, concluding the taxpayer “must bear the responsibility for permitting excessive claims to be made in his income tax returns.” This case represents yet another reminder to advisors to ensure that we, and our clients, keep adequate records and copies of all receipts to support any claim for expense deductibility on our income tax returns.